Rugby Referee Analysis: South Africa vs Ireland 2nd Test
What a series it has been between South Africa and Ireland. It’s a realy pity that we won’t get to see a third tech as this is such a great modern day rivalry. The Springboks vs Ireland seems to produce close games every time thet play each other. This was another classic where Ireland came out as the deserved victors of the game, but it’s sad to see that we’re still getting poor officiating and mainly from the TMO, who has been subpar these last couple of games. I cover some of the controversies of the game some of the main ones includes Caelan Doris’ yellow card and his dangerous cleanout on Malcolm Marx, alongside James Ryan. This was controversial because we had James Ryan who charged into the ruck off his feet, and the ref and TMO seemed to ignore his foul play, all because Doris’ foul play occured first. That should not matter and both players should’ve gotten carded.
Then we had the last drop goal of the game, to me it wasn’t very controversial as Cheslin Kolbe was not blocked, Caelan Doris had all the right to stand his ground and give make Kolbe run around him. It was just a smart play by Doris and an even better drop goal by Ciaran Frawley.
Then we had the scrums, there’s too much to talk about, it’s better to just watch the video as I go over the scrums.
Again, we as fans just want consistency. And I do feel for the referees, as the laws are just too complex to referee and there seems to be a lack of good TMO’s at the moment which also puts extra pressure on the referees to perform. It’s frustrating to see the same mistakes week in and week out. We just want consistency, is it too much to ask for?
00:00 - Caelan Doris Yellow Card
02:55 - Ireland Drop Goal
04:00 - Kwagga Smith “Knock On“
05:23 - Scrum Analysis
08:02 - Missed Calls
The officials for the game:
Referee: Karl Dickson
Assistant Referees: Luke Pearce, Craig Evans
Television Match Official: Ian Tempest
Copyright and Fair Dealing Disclaimer
Under Section 12 of the Copyright Act No. 98 of 1978, as amended, allowance is made for “Fair Dealing” for purposes such as criticism or review. Fair Dealing is a use permitted by the Copyright Act that might otherwise be infringing.
2 views
29
4
2 months ago 00:34:48 6
Richie McCaw - The Greatest All Black
4 months ago 00:10:28 2
Rugby Referee Analysis: South Africa vs Ireland 2nd Test
4 months ago 00:20:05 3
20 Minutes of BRUTAL Rugby Red Card Incidents
4 months ago 00:09:54 5
Did the Referee Rob the Bulls? Analyzing Controversial Calls in the URC 2024 Final
4 months ago 00:05:53 5
Rugby Doesn’t Make Sense Anymore: Controversial Calls in Springboks vs Wales 2024
5 months ago 00:09:37 1
Rugby Refereeing But It Gets Increasingly Worse
6 months ago 00:08:21 4
8 Minutes of Quade Cooper’s Most Unbelievable Rugby Plays | Ankle Break, Skill & Pass
8 months ago 00:01:00 1
Bro asking for penalty after all that 🙈😂 #futsal #gohardorgohome #shoulder #barge #tackle #shorts
8 months ago 00:04:30 7
When The Referee Gets Replaced!
9 months ago 00:05:43 8
Refereeing Analysis: France vs Ireland Clash Sparks Bunker System Debate
10 months ago 00:01:57 4
What rugby refereeing is really like | Whistleblowers trailer | RugbyPass TV
10 months ago 00:11:44 1
The Halfbacks | Squidge Team of the Year 2023
12 months ago 00:16:06 7
Wayne Barnes at his glorious BEST! | Referee Grand Master
12 months ago 00:05:29 23
When rugby players act like footballers to referees
1 year ago 00:01:09 7
Irish supporters Cranberries ZOMBIE 23 09 23 rugby world cup - after Ireland vs South Africa 🍀🍀🍀
1 year ago 00:12:40 35
Funny & Hilarious 2023 Rugby World Cup Moments | Springboks Rugby
1 year ago 00:00:00 2
Springbok Women vs Samoa
1 year ago 00:21:50 155
World Rugby’s Shame: Unforgivable Officiating in South Africa vs. Ireland Clash