Eastern vs Western Siegecraft: When the Chinese Besieged a Russian Star Fortress in 1686
Don’t sleep on solving your internet problems while travelling and go to and use the code sandrhoman to get an exclusive 15% off your first purchase.
In 1686, Chinese cannons bombarded the Russian fortress of Albazin for several weeks. The Qing Kangxi Emperor had sent an army to the frigid and inhospitable east of Siberia to capture the fortress and stop the expansion of the Tsardom of Russia in the region. But despite relentless bombardment, superior numbers, and ferocious assaults, his troops still struggled to capture the fortress. This was not due to any fundamental inferiority of the Chinese forces to the Tsardom’s troops. Instead, the trouble arose from the clash of Eastern siege methods with a Western-style star fortress with bastions. Chinese siege tactics differed significantly from those practiced in the West, which typically featured massive fortifications with bastions, systematic trench digging, and the use of heavy artillery. In this video, we’ll investigate the reasons for these differences and examine how early modern Chinese siege warfare differed from that in Europe.
Patreon (thank you):
Paypal (thank you:
Twitter:
Some must read mlitary history books:
Ambrose, S. E., Band of Brothers: E Company, 2001.
Baime, A. J., The Accidental President: Harry S. Truman, 2017.
Beard, M., Emperor of Rome: Ruling the Ancient Roman World, 2023.
Bevoor, A., Stalingrad: The Fateful Siege: 1942-1943, 1999.
Beevor, A., The Second World War, 2013.
Brennan, P D., Gettysburg in Color, 2022.
Clausewitz, C., On War, 2010.
Kaushik, R., A Global History of Pre-Modern Warfare: 10,000 BCE–1500 CE, 2021.
McPherson, J., Battle Cry of Freedom, The Civil War Era, 2021.
Tsu, S., The Art of War, 2007,
Sledge. E. B., With the Old Breed: At Peleliu and Okinawa, 2008.
Pomerantsev, P., How to Win an Information War, 2024.
Bibliography
Andrade, Tonio, Siegecraft in Ming and Qing China, in: Fischer-Kattner, Anke / Ostwald, Jamel (Eds.), The World of the Siege. Representations of Early Modern Positional Warfare, Leiden/Boston 2019, pp. 243-264.
Andrade, Tonio, The Gunpowder Age: China, Military Innovation, and the Rise of the West in World History, Princeton 2016.
Andrade, Tonio, Lost Colony. The Untold Story of China’s First Great Victory over the West, Princeton 2011.
Chung, Michael Yan Hon, The Introduction of European-Style Artillery and the Reform of Siege Tactics in 17th Century China-a Case Study of the Tragedy of Jiangyin (1645), in: Journal of Chinese Military History 9 (2020), pp. 1-37.
De Lucca, Denis, Jesuits and Fortifications: The Contribution of the Jesuits to Military Architecture in the Baroque Age, Leiden 2012.
3 views
71
25
2 months ago 00:06:14 1
Public vs Private Companies - What’s the difference between a public and private company?
2 months ago 00:11:10 1
How Putin fooled Ukraine, Zelenskyy’s Kursk plan backfires
2 months ago 00:09:36 1
Chaos erupts in Israel as Houthis go hypersonic
2 months ago 01:16:10 1
LFL | 2017 | WEEK 18 | EASTERN CONFERENCE CHAMPIONSHIP | ATLANTA STEAM VS CHICAGO BLISS
2 months ago 02:10:35 1
The Sun Inside the Earth | Venus Mysteries | Gigi Young
2 months ago 00:30:37 1
Antony Blinken vs Polish Foreign Minister: HIGH TENSION Press Conference
2 months ago 01:45:17 1
Col. Jacques Baud: Israel vs. Hezbollah - Is Ukraine’s Army Doomed?
2 months ago 00:01:26 1
Scott Walker - 2009 Eastern Conference Semifinals Game Seven [Carolina vs Boston]
2 months ago 00:49:06 1
Florida Panthers FULL PLAYOFFS MINI-MOVIE Compilation 🏆
2 months ago 00:14:08 1
Truthear Hexa vs TruthЕar x Crinacle Zero: Red (10 Ohm)
3 months ago 00:29:21 1
Black Myth Wukong - MAX LEVEL 342 Vs Bosses+ NG+++ Gameplay (NO DAMAGE)
3 months ago 00:12:30 1
Why Apple and Other Big Companies Always Invest in South India? Why Not North India?
3 months ago 00:03:13 1
Hours After Hezbollah Attack, Saudi Arabia’s Big Move In Iran Call; USA Loses Biggest Arab Ally?
3 months ago 00:03:23 1
Russians don’t abandon their own #Ukraine #war #footage
3 months ago 00:09:13 1
Hidden Ukraines Inside Russia?
3 months ago 01:09:52 1
Brian Stillwater - FUKD (Promo CD) [2002]
3 months ago 00:32:16 1
How India’s Richest Region Became The Poorest
3 months ago 01:42:44 1
Exploring Pre-Islamic Arabia: New Discoveries Revealed! | Dr. Ahmad Al-Jallad
4 months ago 00:03:04 1
On Cam: Hamas Attacks Shock IDF In Gaza Amid Iran Vs Israel; Unstoppable Even Without Haniyeh, Deif?
4 months ago 00:10:05 1
GTA IV: 2008 vs 2023 Definitive Edition Graphics Concept Comparison - RTX OFF vs ON / GTA 5 PC Mod
4 months ago 00:30:38 5
12 Best Places To Visit In Bulgaria | Bulgaria Travel Guide
4 months ago 00:16:06 1
Eastern vs Western Siegecraft: When the Chinese Besieged a Russian Star Fortress in 1686
4 months ago 02:11:53 1
Oi! INDONESIA vs JAPAN
4 months ago 00:24:13 1
Satanic Faceless Void vs Yopaj Skem SERVER PERU BATTLE EPIC GAME